Why We Need Rest (And Why It's Not as Simple as "Just Relax")
The Midnight Cart Test
Here's the thing about willpower: it's not some bottomless well you can dip into whenever you fancy. It behaves more like your phone battery, cruising along fine in the morning and sitting on 3% by 9pm, low power mode, apps quietly closing themselves in the background. Psychologists have a name for this: decision fatigue (or, if you want to sound extra fancy at a dinner party, "ego depletion"). The theory goes that every choice you make in a day, what to wear, how to word that email, whether to actually reply to your group chat, draws from the same limited tank of mental energy.
Which is exactly why you can scroll straight past a sales email at 7am without a second thought, but by 9pm, after a full day of adulting, that same "only 2 left in stock" banner suddenly looks less like marketing and more like the answer to all your problems, and somehow there are four things in your cart you don't remember adding. This isn't a character flaw (a 9pm splurge never is, even at 7am). It's just what happens when the part of your brain responsible for self-control has clocked off for the day, same as the rest of you. One of the foundational studies on this (Baumeister et al., 1998) found that after people exerted self-control on one task, their capacity to exert it again on a completely unrelated task dropped significantly. Willpower, it turns out, is a shared, finite resource, not a separate tap for each area of your life. (Some later research has quibbled over the exact mechanism, but if you've ever met yourself at 9pm, you already know the gist is right.)
So no, needing rest isn't you being soft. It's basic maintenance for the system running every decision you make, all day, every day. It's also vital burnout prevention, necessary for a self-compassionate relationship, and Just. Plain. Mandatory. So why aren't we better at it?
Rest Isn't One Size Fits All
Here's where it gets interesting though: rest doesn't look the same for everyone, and if you're someone whose brain craves variety, doing "the one relaxing thing" on repeat isn't rest, it's a slow march towards boredom wearing a rest costume. Some days your nervous system might want a completely mindless task (hello, folding washing while watching trash telly). Other days it wants a proper adventure. Both can be restful. The goal isn't to find The One Correct Resting Activity and do it forever, it's to build yourself a whole menu.
Capacity Isn't a Flat Line, So Your Rest Can't Be Either
Your energy on a Tuesday after a big week is not the same as your energy on a chilled-out Sunday, and your rest needs to flex with that rather than fight it. A rigid rest routine (say, "I must do 20 minutes of stretching every single night no matter what") can actually backfire, because it treats rest as a box to tick rather than a response to what your body and brain are actually asking for. Real rest is less "set schedule" and more "responsive relationship." Check in with your capacity, then let your rest meet you there.
What Feels Safe Is Different for Everyone
This is a big one: what feels restful and safe to your nervous system might feel like nails on a chalkboard to someone else's, and neither of you is doing it wrong. I'm someone who needs a little bit of noise, movement and activity even in my slower moments. Total stillness and silence doesn't feel restful to me, it feels unsettling. Meanwhile, plenty of people need exactly that, absolute quiet, no stimulation, stillness, to actually feel like they've rested. There's no universally "correct" version of rest. There's only the version that helps your particular nervous system feel safe enough to actually downshift.
There's No "Should" in Rest (But There Is One Rule)
Rest doesn't have to look calm, quiet, or Pinterest-aesthetic to count. It can be loud, active, silly, or slightly chaotic. There are no "shoulds" here. But there is one non-negotiable: whatever you're doing needs to actually top up your battery, even a little bit, not just look like it should on paper.
This is important, because plenty of things are fun, thrilling, delicious, or objectively "good" by the world's standards, and still leave you feeling completely wrung out afterwards. That doesn't automatically make them bad, they might be great for your soul, brilliant for balance, or just something you genuinely love. But if it drains your tank rather than filling it, it's not rest, it's an expense. Which is fine, as long as you're budgeting for it (with energy) and not accidentally counting it as your rest for the week when really it's the opposite.
"I'm Too Busy for Rest"
Are you too busy for burnout, though? Because that's really the trade you're making. Rest isn't a luxury add-on for people with more spare time than you, it's burnout prevention, plain and simple. And burnout doesn't discriminate or negotiate. It doesn't check your calendar first. It doesn't say, "Oh, you're a busy Mum and you genuinely can't slow down right now? No worries, I'll leave you alone and come back later when it's more convenient." It just arrives, uninvited, usually at the worst possible moment, and hands you the bill for however long you've been running on empty.
Rest isn't the thing you do once everything else is finished. It's what keeps you able to do everything else at all.
So, Where Does That Leave You?
At the end of the day (around midnight-checkout o'clock), rest isn't a reward you unlock, a box you tick, or a personality trait some people simply "have" and others don't. It's maintenance. Unglamorous, absolutely essential maintenance, the same way you'd charge your phone without treating it as a moral failing that the battery ran down in the first place. Your brain deserves the same grace you'd give a phone at 3%. So here's your homework, if you want it: start a running list, on your phone, on a sticky note, wherever, of anything that's ever actually topped up your tank, no matter how small, silly, or un-Pinterest it looks. Loud things and quiet things. Five-minute things and whole-afternoon things. Then, next time you're running on empty, don't reach for "the one relaxing thing" you think you're supposed to do, check in with where your capacity actually is that day, and pick off the menu instead. Some days that's noise-cancelling headphones and total silence. Some days it's dancing badly in your kitchen. Both count, as long as you come out the other side with more in the tank than you started with. That's the whole test. Not whether it looks restful. Whether it is.
IF YOU OR SOMEONE YOU KNOW IS STRUGGLING
If something in this post has brought up difficult feelings for you, or you’re concerned about someone you know, support is available.
For immediate support, you can contact Lifeline on 13 11 14 or Kids Helpline on 1800 55 1800.
If you or someone else is in immediate danger, please call 000.
Please note that Brianna Thomas Psychology is not a crisis service and enquiries are not monitored 24/7.
Reference:
Baumeister, R. F., Bratslavsky, E., Muraven, M., & Tice, D. M. (1998). Ego depletion: Is the active self a limited resource? Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 74(5), 1252–1265.
